Source, paywall: https://boosty.to/cluborlov/posts/
European blowback from the Ukrainian defeat
How long do European business and political establishments intend to continue to pretend that they are going to deal Russia a strategic defeat with the assistance of the former Ukraine? The answer is determined not by any genuine conviction — there is nothing genuine about it — but by the approaching exhaustion of the material and political resources that sustain this narrative. While growing social unrest within the EU and NATO countries can no longer be concealed, it is yet to result in a shift in policy. For the time being, for the ruling elites, the cost of abandoning the current course remains higher than the cost of staying the course. At present, the 2027–2028 timeframe appears the most likely period during which a combination of financial, political and physical constraints will render any further persistence on their part purely irrational. Even this does not imply that they will stop; but if they do not stop, they will fail most spectacularly.
Europe’s financial resources are not infinite, and their eventual depletion can already be foreseen. The EU has shifted toward collective borrowing to continue supporting the former Ukraine — thereby crossing a Rubicon previously blocked by Germany — and is now discussing a new €45 billion package to cover the Kiev regime’s budget gap for 2027. These loans are backed by frozen Russian assets. Any peace agreement would entail returning those assets to Moscow with interest and penalties and would leave European governments no choice but shift these liabilities to their own taxpayers, who are already rebelling. The longer the Europeans persist with their narrative of “as long as it takes,” the deeper will they bury themselves under a mountain of debt. The only escape from this trap would be a radical reworking of the entire European political framework involving a complete change of staff at the very top. Some glimmers of this realization can already be seen within Europe’s financial ministries.
The 2027 electoral cycle is ready to provide the primary flashpoint. National elections are set to take place in Spain, France, Poland, and Italy — four of the five most populous EU member states. Marine Le Pen, the frontrunner in the French presidential race, has promised to halt aid to Ukraine within six months of taking office and to drastically cut France’s contributions to the EU budget. Analysts at Eurasia Group explicitly identify 2027 as the moment when “political, electoral, policy and economic realities will catch up with Europe,” making it impossible to sustain, never mind increase, support for the former Ukraine. For now, however, European elites are clinging to the status quo — precisely because acknowledging the current impasse would hand a victory to Eurosceptics and the far-right just months before the elections.
An intra-European rift has already become part of Europe’s institutional framework, though it is yet to lead to a change in policy. For months, Hungary has blocked a €90 billion loan and has consistently opposed the former Ukraine’s accelerated accession to the EU. Instead, Hungary called for an immediate ceasefire and negotiations with Moscow. Neither of these would be acceptable to Moscow, which has good reasons to look forward to an outright victory. As of now, however, this remains the position of a single state rather than a coalition. A point of no return may be reached once at least one major country joins Hungary — a development that might occur following the French elections, rather than as a result of any internal evolution within the current ruling elites.
The forecast, therefore, is as follows: European business and political structures will continue to insist on their own, increasingly fictional version of reality until roughly the end of 2027, with their recalcitrance peaking in the period leading up to the French elections. Afterward, one of two things will happen: either Le Pen will fulfill her campaign promise and the coalition will collapse from within, or — even if she loses — financial exhaustion and pressure from the electorate will force Paris and Berlin to seek a formula for some sort of negotiated, face-saving exit, supposedly on European terms but, in essence, a capitulation of the old European order. Hungarian journalist Gábor Stier estimates that the minimum time required to reach a genuine agreement is “a year — or, in a best-case scenario, by next spring or summer.” This, however, is an optimistic scenario that assumes that Europe can resolve its internal divisions before being compelled to do so by its voters and its bankers. A more realistic assessment is that the current narrative will persist only as long as it is being paid for — while the costs are rising steadily.
If we were to try to assess the total losses incurred by Europe in connection with the Ukrainian crisis — starting in 2014, but with the primary impact occurring after the start of Russia’s Special Military Operation in February of 2022 — the figures would amount to several trillion euros. It is impossible to provide an exact number, as the total is composed of direct budgetary expenditures, lost trade opportunities, and indirect damage resulting from inflation and the energy crisis.
However, it is possible to approximate the total based on statements from officials and expert assessments. Three main categories of costs can be identified.
First, there is direct financial and military aid. According to Kaja Kallas, the EU’s foreign policy chief, the total value of aid provided to Ukraine by the EU and its member states since the beginning of the conflict exceeds €220 billion. Kallas is a singularly incompetent being. In her recent attempt to insinuate herself into Russian peace negotiations, she has been felicitously compared to an earthworm volunteering for a fishing expedition. So ridiculous has this granddaughter of a Nazi and daughter of a Soviet official become that she deserves a new moniker; perhaps Lady Kaka? But we digress…
But then former Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán offered a similar (and perhaps similarly inaccurate) estimate: approximately €180 billion spent by the European Union over three years. If one adds to this the military and financial support from the United States and other NATO countries, the West’s total expenditure on sustaining the former Ukraine during the SMO has exceeded $320 billion.
Next, there is the energy crisis and the refusal to buy Russian energy resources. These represent the largest category of indirect losses. According to estimates by Vladimir Putin, the damage to the eurozone resulting solely from the rejection of Russian gas has amounted to approximately €200 billion, while Russia’s special representative Kirill Dmitriev offers a more drastic assessment, claiming that Europe has lost $3 trillion due to the abandonment of Russian gas and the associated economic harm. Lest you dismiss these estimates as Russian propaganda, in 2024, the European Commission itself estimated the total damage to the European economy caused by the energy crisis at €1 trillion.
Finally, there are Europe’s losses that resulted from anti-Russian sanctions and the severing of trade ties with Russia. Estimates vary depending on the calculation methodology. European Union’s losses from sanctions imposed since 2014 amounted to $240 billion as of 2019. Projections for 2025–2026 indicate that the EU’s total losses from the curtailment of economic ties with Russia and the implementation of the 19 sanctions packages range from €1.5 trillion to €2.5 trillion. It is worth noting that over the course of the SMO Russia’s economy expanded by 10% and that its trade has expanded considerably, shifting away from dollars and euros. Thus, the logic behind the anti-Russian sanctions is an enigma wrapped in a farce.
A rough overall estimate, summing up only the lower-end figures for direct expenditures (~€200 billion), the energy crisis (~€1 trillion), and losses from sanctions (~€1.5 trillion), is that Europe has lost at least €2.7 trillion between 2022 and 2025. If, however, we consider the upper-end expert estimates — including the €3 trillion in lost opportunities related to the loss of Russian natural gas — the cumulative damage to the European economy over the decade (2014–2025) approaches €4–5 trillion.
These staggeringly huge numbers explain why a sense of unease within European elites is growing more intense: it is impossible to suffer such losses indefinitely without destroying Europe’s own social and industrial base. This truism is already reflected in the budgets of Germany and France, where spending on the former Ukraine has been substantially curtailed.
Given that the conflict in the former Ukraine is still ongoing, and considering how far Europe still is from accepting Russia’s conditions for peace, which were spelled out at the end of 2021 and which remain fixed it may take many more years for conditions to stabilize. In the meantime, we could easily see another €1, 2, or 3 trillion wiped out. Will the European Union last that long?
If, back in 2014, when they embarked on this endeavor — clearly not for the sake of a democratic, free Ukraine, but rather to use Ukraine as a battering ram with which to crack open Russia’s sovereignty for European neocolonial expansion — the Europeans had known the true costs and, in particular, the cost of their failure, would they have proceeded as planned? In other words, do the Europeans plan to plead mere feeble-mindedness or outright insanity?
Here is the number to keep in mind: by the time it is all over, the total losses for Europe resulting from their ill-fated campaign in the former Ukraine could reach the €6–8 trillion mark.
Share this
Views: 26