Tap News
Tap News Log in Register ☰

This time it’s different: wisdom of crowds vs. western propaganda – Alex Krainer’s TrendCompass

 Thu 8:04 pm Europe/London, 23 Feb 2023  
posted by danceaway

The powers-that-be failed spectacularly on two mission-critical fronts

Alex Krainer
33 min ago
2

The “Wisdom of Crowds,” a hypothesis popularized by James Surowiecki in his 2005 book of the same title, is among the most fascinating discoveries about the collective human psychology. It’s an antithesis to Charles Mackay‘s “Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds.” In a nutshell, Surowiecky suggests that under certain conditions, the crowds can converge on the truth about some matter or zero in on most effective solutions to a problem more accurately and more reliably than even the best qualifie experts in that problem matter. I will skip the discussion of concrete cases of this mysterious phenomenon, but for all who are interested, I summarized two of Surowiecki’s most fascinating examples in my book “Mastering Uncertainty in Commodities Trading” (free download at link, you’ll find the relevant discussion on pages 58 and 59).

Social media are making us remarkably smart

But in order for the crowds to manifest such wisdom, a number of conditions must be satisfied: (1) the flow of information must be decentralized; (2) truthful information must be present within the information universe; (3) there has to be a wide diversity of participants in the discussion, and (4) the participants must not be dependent upon each other in making their judgments.

Modern social media may have created an environment where these conditions have satisfied in a robust way, which radically changed the way we respond to information as a collective. Until not so long ago, information flowed from centralized sources which filtered the information that reached the public. For as long as the society depended on the printed word, radio or TV for information, controlling the flow of information and shaping the narratives was relatively straightforward.

Spontaneous detoxing from Russophobia

The emergence of social media may have upended this quaint order of things, and the perfect example of this is the current conflict between Russia and the west. Over the past two decades, western legacy media have kept a tight control over the narrative about Russia and its leadership. Adversarial positioning toward Russia has been one of the western powers’ key policy priorities and the media coverage about Russia has been consistently negative.

When Vladimir Pozner commissioned a group of researchers to comb through the archives of the New York Times over a 3-year period from 2015 through 2017 and look up Russia-related articles, they found zero stories that mentioned Russia in any positive context. The same is probably true of other western media too. On a rare occasion when a positive story escapes the watchful eyes of the censors, such stories are soon deleted and memory-holed.

The narrative control went turbo-charged last year from the day Russia invaded Ukraine: western powers almost completely purged all Russian sources and applied heavy-handed censorship of pro-Russian views.

In light of all this, one would expect to encounter uniformly negative views about Russia in the west. How else should we perceive a nation with zero redeeming qualities, led by a thuggish kleptocracy under a President who is a former KGB agent? And now that this nation started an unprovoked, illegal aggression of a neighboring sovereign country, we’d expect Russia to arouse nothing but fear, loathing and hostility in the west. But that’s not what happened; it seems that such sentiments are limited to public officials and mainstream media, but are not generally shared among the public.

That didn’t go as planned

While it is true that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine caused shock and consternation among people in the west, the initial condemnation of Russia has largely dissipated. In Croatia, which is a catholic nation that’s never been particularly close with Russia, probably three out of four people sympathize with the Russian side. This has been my own impression, shared by many people I spoke with there. A number of informal polls I encountered on social media during the recent months corroborate this sentiment. Here are three examples that gained a relatively large number of votes on Twitter:

Neither of the three Twitter accounts that conducted these polls appear particularly pro-Russian, so the results should not be disregarded. I encountered another handful of polls, showing results that are similarly in discord with the mainstream narrative. Here’s today’s example, courtesy of George Galloway’s Mother of All Talk Shows (MOATS) poll on YouTube:

To be sure, these were not scientific polls. The participants could be from anywhere in the world including Russia, and the results might have been influenced by bots (in either direction, in fact). But I received another corroboration from a surprising source.

Populations in NATO nations not so keen on hating Russia

A few weeks ago I received an email from a person that works for NATO in one of its member nations. They told me that NATO was careful to monitor the public sentiment among its member states. Here’s what they wrote (word for word, including emphasis): “I know from my job (military) that Roumanians, Moldovans, Bulgarians, Hungarians, Slovakians, Cypriots and all the Balkans are circa 3 out of 4 and above with Russia. Austrians, Italians, Czechs, Spaniards and French around 2 out of 3.”

All but the George Galloway’s YouTube poll predate Seymour Hersh’s recent article which points at the Biden Administration as the culprits behind last September’s attacks on Nord Stream pipelines. This bombshell would certainly have moved the sentiment further in Russia’s favor.

This time it really IS different

What we are looking at, in fact, is a massive narrative control failure by the western powers. Maintaining control of the narrative is not just an auxiliary luxury in politics. It is an essential requirement for successful policy conduct and as such it justifies enormous expenditure of resources in formulating the narrative, controlling the information flows and censoring dissenting views. The ruling elites parasites lavishly fund hundreds of think tanks to manufacture the materials with which to contrive compelling narratives and shape public perception.

They have perfected their game with over two centuries’ worth of experience and know-how in the arts of manipulating public opinion. Yet in the last three years we saw them fail spectacularly on two critically important fronts: (1) in their confrontation with Russia and (2) in their attempt to corral us into a dystopian “New Normal” on the back of the Covid 19 pandemic.

They failed because the way we collectively process information, learn and make decisions has changed radically and probably for good. All this should inspire a new faith in humanity and represent compelling grounds for optimism about our future. These changes are also of utmost relevance in the domain of investment speculation, because they’ll impact the price discovery process in ways we can’t yet account for. Whatever might have been the norm over the last decades may have become obsolete as a guidepost for the future.

However, markets wll continue to move in trends and with high quality trend following strategies investors will be able to navigate the coming changes and prosper until we can replace the current monetary system with honest money and the whole business of investment speculation becomes unnecessary.

Thank you for reading! This post is public so feel free to share it.

https://alexkrainer.substack.com/p/this-time-its-different-wisdom-of?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail
Back to Top

The Tap Blog

The blog that's fed by you, the readers. Please send in the news and stories that you think are of interest using the form below.

Search The Tap

Help Support The Tap

If you enjoy the Tap Blog then please help support the hosting costs and site upgrades. Your contributions whatever the amount will help keep this valuable and much loved resource online now and into the future. Thank You!


Under New Management

Get the Full Story



Smart Cities Live Stream 23rd April 2023

The Alternative View presents a four speaker live stream event looking at the subject of Smart Cities and the Surveillance State.

For tickets and info visit www.alternativeview.co.uk

Tap Archives

Recent Posts

  • Amazing channel from North Korean escapee
  • Corruption will end the US empire
  • Nasty Pesticide Broken Down by Probiotic Used In Culturing Food
  • The Origin of April Fool’s Day
  • NATO intensifies attacks
  • The Grayzone – Aaron Mate at the UN; Syria probe was censored by US and UK
  • Washington’s Position in Syria Under Fire (Literally)- Brian Berletic

Sharing

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

Recent Comments

  • ian on The Corona Virus End Game
  • newensign on The Origin of April Fool’s Day
  • newensign on The Origin of April Fool’s Day
  • Gordon on The Origin of April Fool’s Day
  • Gordon on 9/11 and the COVID-19 Hoax in the Transition to Governance by “Emergency Measures”
  • Gordon on NATO intensifies attacks
  • Gordon on The Corona Virus End Game

SUBMIT NEWS

Please complete the required fields.
Please select your image(s) to upload.
Add another image

Reset form

Atom Feed

This site is intended as an informational guide. The remedies approaches and techniques described hearin are meant to supplement, and not be a substitute for, professional, medical care or treatments. Any information is for entertainment purposes only.

Any previous articles which prefix the 8th of February 2023 have no involvement in new upload to this site. Any Copy right infringements are not intended and any such should be made aware to the site for immediate withdraw.

Articles posted here are for your consideration at your discretion. No purported facts have been verified. Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of the poster nor the site owner.

Blog editor - tap[at]alternativeview.co.uk

Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}
Support Us

If you enjoy the Tap Blog then please help support the site hosting and development costs. Your contributions will help keep this valuable and much loved resource online now and into the future. Every pound, dollar or euro is much appreciated. Thank You!