Schools subjected to chaotic testing regime

Seven in 10 positive coronavirus tests in school children are likely to be wrong, experts have warned, as they called on the Government to bring back confirmatory PCR testing.

Biostaticians are concerned that infections in the community are now so low, that false positives …. are vastly outnumbering true cases, leading to real cases being missed and families needlessly being asked to isolate.

Pupils are currently being tested twice a week for coronavirus using lateral flow devices, but real-world data has shown they miss positive cases around 50 per cent of the time.

Similarly, although they pick up 99.9 per cent of negative cases, meaning fewer than 0.1 per cent will be false positives, the prevalence rate is now low enough that false positives will be making a significant contribution to the overall figure.

Previously, positive tests were confirmed using a more accurate polymerase chain reaction (PCR) lab test, but this week the Government admitted it had quietly scrapped the process at the end of January.

It means that thousands of pupils and their families are having to isolate needlessly, and missing more school after months away from classrooms.

Staff direct year 11 school pupils as they take lateral flow tests in the sports hall at Archway School in Stroud
Staff direct year 11 school pupils as they take lateral flow tests in the sports hall at Archway School in Stroud CREDIT: Ben Birchall /PA

Latest figures from NHS Test & Trace show that in secondary schools there were 328 positive cases found in 663,332 tests between February 25 and March 5.

It means that just one in 2,000 pupils are testing positive for the virus. Experts warn that is far lower than the 1 in 270 that the Office for National Statistics (ONS) believes to be the current community prevalence, suggesting large numbers of cases are being missed.

In primary schools 613 positives found from 721,546 tests in primary schools giving an overall school prevalence rate of 0.067 per cent or roughly 1 in 1,500.

With that prevalence rate, if a million tests were conducted 670 should come back positive.

With current testing accuracy, half positive cases (335) would be missed and 1,000 would be false positives. It would mean that out of a total of 1,335 positives, just 25 per cent would be accurate.

Professor Jon Deeks, a biostatistician from the University of Birmingham, said: “We would expect far more false positives than true positives amongst those testing positives in schools.

“There are many uncertainties but given the DHSC data it seems likely that over 70 per cent of positive test results are false positives, potentially many more.  Addition of a confirmatory PCR would add little cost and would most likely reduce false positives to 1 in 1,000,000.

“The refusal to confirm lateral flow results with PCR is at best perplexing, will make testing less attractive, and create harm by wrongly isolating individuals, families and other close contacts.”

Last night, the Royal Statistical Society (RSS) wrote to the Medical and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) warning of the ‘potential harm’ of failing to re-test children.

The RSS warned that there could be ‘legal implications’ for curtailing the freedom of children, classmates and family members on such a flimsy scientific basis and asked for the MHRA to insist on a confirmatory PCR test.

Sage warned false positives would become an issue

In a report to the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (Sage) last year, Dr Carl Mayer and Dr Kate Baker, from the Government Office for Science, warned that Britain would face a problem with false positives once the infection rate became very low.

“When only a small proportion of people being tested have the virus, the operational false positive rate becomes very important,” they wrote in their report.

They warned that there was risk of overestimating the Covid-19 incidence, and the demand on test and trace.

Profesor Carl Henegehan, director of the Centre for Evidence Based Medicine at Oxford University said: “This becomes a huge problem when you have low prevalence. We have been working for years to try and minimise this problem of false positives in mass testing programmes.

“Once you’re doing the levels of testing we’re doing, you’re false positive threshold will exceed the test positivity threshold and so testing becomes of limited value.”

This week, the Department of Health said the accuracy of lateral flow tests was 99.9 per cent and could be as high as 99.97 per cent. But even at the upper end, the chance of a test being correct with the current school prevalence rate would only be around 50 per cent.

Prof Sheila Bird, formerly programme leader of the MRC Biostatistics Unit at University of Cambridge, said: “NHS Test & Trace and Public Health England have attempted to justify not offering PCR during school-monitored use of lateral flow devices for asymptomatic screening of secondary pupils on their return to school in England.

“More than 600 positives can be expected this week when over 1.5 million asymptomatic secondary pupils have been screened.

“Half may be PCR-negative. By withholding data and denying PCR-confirmations, the half who are PCR-negative will never know – unless families and schools demand fairness for our children.”

 

Daily Telegraph

sent by Robin Tilbrook, Chairman English Democrats

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

4 Responses to “Schools subjected to chaotic testing regime”

  1. Tapestry says:

    COVID vanished a while ago. We now have vaccine deaths being covered up by all kinds of measures like mass school testing, and all the other nonsenses. I have been in contact with my son’s school as I believe they may be excluding non testing pupils, which is of course totally illegal. If exclusion persists I will instruct lawyers to proceed against the school. The testing and mask wearing are both being carried out illegally on a number of counts, one being that schools must inform students of the risks before asking for consent. This they are not doing.

    • Aldous says:

      I have (financial) scores to settle with a few hateful bastards who have disappointed and pissed me off this past year with their embracement of all things Covid.
      Hit them where it counts and hurts. They had a choice and chose poorly.

  2. Aldous says:

    It is absolutely disgusting what is happening. The engineered killing of the elderly is bad enough but the engineered and permanent damaging of children with their whole lives ahead of them is beyond belief.

  3. Aldous says:

    The enforced (and pointless) mask wearing/face covering and social distancing is clearly and obviously a physically and mentally damaging agenda(s) which is intended to subjugate those who willingly or unwittingly acquiesce to it.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.