Through this letter I express my unequivocal condemnation of Amnesty International with regards to the destabilizing role it has played in Nicaragua, my country of birth.
I open this letter quoting Donatella Rovera, who at the time of speaking had been one of Amnesty International’s field investigators for more than 20 years:
“Conflict situations create highly politicized and polarized environments… Players and interested parties go to extraordinary lengths to manipulate or manufacture ‘evidence’ for both internal and external consumption. A recent – though by no means the only – example is provided by the Syrian conflict in what is often referred to as the ‘YouTube war,’ with a myriad techniques employed to manipulate video footage of incidents which occurred at other times in other places – including in other countries – and present them as ‘proof’ of atrocities committed by one or other parties to the conflict in Syria.”
Rovera’s remarks, made in 2014, properly describe the situation in Nicaragua today, where even the preamble of the crisis was manipulated to generate rejection of the Nicaraguan government. Amnesty International’s maliciously titled report –‘Shoot to Kill: Nicaragua’s Strategy to Repress Protest’ – could be dismantled point by point, but doing so requires precious time that the Nicaraguan people don’t have, therefore I will concentrate on two main points:
1. The report completely lacks neutrality
2. Amnesty International’s role is contributing to the chaos in which the nation finds itself
The operating narrative, agreed upon by the local opposition and the corporate western media, is as follows: that President Daniel Ortega sought to cut 5 percent from retirees’ monthly retirement checks and that he was going to increase contributions, made by employees and employers, into the social security system. The reforms sparked protests, the response to which was a government-ordered genocide of peaceful protesters: more than 60, mostly students. A day or two after that, the Nicaraguan government would wait until nightfall to send its police force out in order to decimate the Nicaraguan population, night after night, city by city, in the process destroying its own public buildings and killing its own police force, to then culminate its murderous rampage with a Mothers’ Day massacre, and so on.
While the above narrative is not uniformly expressed by all anti-government actors, the unifying elements are that the government is committing genocide, and that the president and vice-president must go.
Amnesty International’s assertions are mostly based on testimony by anti-government witnesses and victims, or uncorroborated and highly manipulated information emitted by U.S.-financed anti-government media outlets and non-profit organizations, collectively known as ‘civil society.’
The three main media organizations cited by the report – Confidencial, 100% Noticias, and La Prensa – are sworn enemies of the Ortega government. Most of these opposition news media organizations – along with some, if not all, of the main non-profits cited by the report – are funded by the United States through organizations such as the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and the National Endowment for Democracy (NED), which has been characterized by retired U.S. Congressman Ron Paul as “an organization that uses U.S. tax money to actually subvert democracy, by showering funding on favored political parties or movements overseas. It underwrites color-coded ‘people’s revolutions’ overseas that look more like pages out of Lenin’s writings on stealing power than genuine Indigenous democratic movements.”
Amnesty’s report heavily relies on 100% Noticias, an anti-government news outlet that has aired manipulated and inflammatory material to generate hatred against the Nicaraguan government, including footage of peaceful protesters – unaware of the fact that the protesters were carrying pistols and rifles and were shooting at police officers during incidents reported by the network as acts of police repression of opposition marches. On Mothers’ Day, 100% Noticias reported the purported shooting of unarmed protesters by police marksmen, including an incident in which a young man’s brains were spilling out of his skull. The network followed the report with a photograph that Rovera would refer to as an incident “which occurred at other times in other places.” The picture included in the report was quickly met on social media by links to past online articles depicting the same image.
One of the sources (footnote #77) cited to corroborate the alleged denial of medical care at state hospitals to patients injured at opposition events – one of the main accusations repeated and reaffirmed by Amnesty International – is a press conference published by La Prensa, in which the chief of surgery denies claims he had been fired, or that hospital officials denied care to protesters at the beginning of the conflict. “I repeat,” he is heard saying, “as the chief of surgery, I repeat order: to take care of, I will be clear, to take care of the entire population that comes here, without investigating anything at all.” In other words, one of Amnesty International’s own sources contradicts one of the report’s main claims.
The above-mentioned examples of manipulated and manufactured evidence, to borrow the words of Amnesty’s own investigator, are just a small sample, but they capture the essence of this modality of U.S.-sponsored regime change. The report feeds on claims from those on one side of the conflict and relies on deeply corrupted evidence. It ultimately helps create the mirage of a genocidal state, in turn generating more anti-government sentiment locally and abroad, and paving the way for ever more aggressive foreign intervention.
A Different Narrative
The original reforms to social security were not proposed by the Sandinista government, but by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and they were supported by an influential business group known as COSEP. They included raising the retirement age from 60 to 65 and doubling the number of quotas necessary to get full social security from 750 to 1500. Among the impacted retirees, approximately 53,000 are the families of combatants who died in the armed conflict of the 1980s, from both the Sandinista army and the ‘Contras’: the mercenary army financed by the U.S. government in the 1980s, around the same time the NED was created, in part, to stop the spread of Sandinismo in Latin America.
The Nicaraguan government countered the IMF reforms by rejecting the cutting out of any retirees, with a proposed 5 percent cut to all retirement checks, an increase in all contributions to the social security system, and with fiscal reform that removed a tax-ceiling that protected Nicaragua’s biggest salaries from higher taxation. The business sector was furious and together with non-governmental organizations organized the first marches, using the pretext of the reforms in the same manipulative way Amnesty International’s report explains them: “The reform increased social security contributions by both employers and employees and imposed an additional 5 percent contribution on pensioners.”
The continuing narrative, repeated and validated by Amnesty International, is that the protesters are peaceful and the genocidal government is irrationally bent on committing atrocities in plain sight. Meanwhile, the number of dead among Sandinista supporters and police officers continues to rise. The report states that ballistic investigations suggest that those shooting at protesters are likely trained snipers, pointing to government involvement, but fails to mention that many of the victims are Sandinistas, regular citizens and police officers. It also does not mention that the ‘peaceful protesters’ have burned down and destroyed more than 60 public buildings, among them many city halls, Sandinista houses, markets, artisan shops, radio stations and more. Nor does it mention that the protesters have established ‘tranques’ (roadblocks) in order to debilitate the economy as a tactic to oust the government. Such ‘tranques’ have become extremely dangerous scenes where murder, robbery, kidnapping and the rape of at least one child have taken place; a young pregnant woman whose ambulance wasn’t let through died on May 17. All of these crimes occur daily and are highly documented, but aren’t included in Amnesty International’s report.
While the organization is right to criticize the government’s belittling response to the initial protests, such response was not entirely untrue. According to the report, Vice-President Murillo said: “They (the protesters) had made up the reports of fatalities… as part of an anti-government strategy.” What Amnesty leaves out is that several of the students reported dead later turned up alive – one of them in Spain – while others weren’t killed at rallies, nor were they students or activists: one died from a stray bullet and another died in bed from a heart attack.
Amnesty’s report also leaves out that many students have deserted the movement, alleging there are criminals entrenched at universities and the various ‘tranques’ who are only interested in destabilizing the nation. Those criminals have created a state of sustained fear among the population, imposing ‘taxes’ on those who want passage; persecuting those who refuse to be detained; kidnapping, beating and torturing them, and setting their cars on fire. In one common practice, they undress their victims, paint their naked bodies in public with the blue and white of the Nicaraguan flag then set them free, prompting them to run right before shooting them with homemade mortars. All of this information, which did not make the report, is available in numerous videos and other sources.
The most basic review of the history between Nicaragua and the United States will show a clear rivalry. Beginning in the mid-1800s, Nicaragua has been resisting U.S. intervention in its domestic affairs, a resistance that continued through the 20th century: first with General August C. Sandino’s fight in the 1920s and 30s, then with the Sandinistas – organized as the Sandinista National Liberation Front (FSLN) – which overthrew the U.S.-supported, 40-year Somoza family dictatorship in 1979. The FSLN, despite having gained power through armed struggle, called for elections shortly after its triumph in 1984, and eventually lost to yet another U.S.-supported coalition of right-wing political parties in 1990. The FSLN once again managed, aided by pacts made with the church and the opposition, to win the election of 2006 and has remained in power since.
In addition to Nicaragua’s close ties with Venezuela, Cuba, Russia and especially China, with whom the country signed a contract to build a canal, the other main reason the United States is after the Sandinistas is Nicaragua’s highly successful economic model, which represents an existential threat to the neoliberal economic order imposed by the United States and its allies.
Despite always being among the poorest nations in the American continent and the world, Nicaragua has managed – since Ortega returned to power in 2007 – to cut poverty by three quarters. Prior to the protests in April, the economy sustained a steady annual economic growth of about 5 percent for several years; the country had the third fastest-growing economy in Latin America, and Nicaragua was one of the safest nations in the region.
The government’s infrastructural upgrades have facilitated trade among Nicaragua’s poorest citizens; they have created universal access to education: primary, secondary and university; there are programs on land, housing, nutrition and more; the healthcare system, while modest, is not only excellent but accessible to everyone. Approximately 90 percent of the food consumed by Nicaraguans is produced in Nicaragua, and about 70 percent of jobs come from the grassroots economy – rather than from transnational corporations – including from small investors from the United States and Europe who have moved to the country and are now a driving force behind the tourism industry.
The audacity of success – of giving its poorest citizens a life with dignity, of being an example of sovereignty to wealthier, more powerful nations, all in direct contradiction to the neoliberal model and its emphasis on privatization and austerity – has once again placed Nicaragua in the crosshairs of U.S. intervention. Imagine the example to other nations, their economies already strangled by neoliberal policies, becoming aware of one of the poorest countries on earth being able to feed its people and grow its economy without throwing its poorest citizens under the iron boot of capitalism. The United States will never tolerate such a dangerous example.
The Nicaraguan government has deficiencies and contradictions to work on, like all governments, and as a Sandinista myself I would like to see the party transformed in various important ways, both internally and externally. I have refrained from writing of those deficiencies and contradictions, however, because the violent protests and ensuing chaos we have seen are not the result of the Nicaraguan government’s shortcomings, but rather of its many successes; that inconvenient truth is the reason the United States and its allies, including Amnesty International, have chosen to “create highly politicized and polarized environments… and go to extraordinary lengths to manipulate or manufacture ‘evidence’ for both internal and external consumption.”
At a time when even the Organization of American States, the United Nations and the Vatican have called for peaceful and constitutional reforms as the only way out of the conflict, Amnesty International has continued to beseech the international community to not “abandon the Nicaraguan people.” Such a biased stance, obscenely bloated on highly manipulated, distorted and one-sided information, has made the terrible situation in Nicaragua even worse. The loss of Nicaraguan lives, including the blood of those ignored by Amnesty International, has been used to manufacture the ‘evidence’ used in the organization’s report, which makes the organization complicit in what future foreign intervention might fall upon the Nicaraguan people. It is now up to the organization to correct that wrong and to do so in a way that reflects a firm commitment first and foremost to the truth – wherever it might fall – and to neutrality, peace, democracy and always to the sovereignty of every nation on earth.
Camilo E. Mejia
Iraq war veteran, resister and conscientious objector (2003-2004); Amnesty International prisoner of conscience (June 2004).
I want to thank everyone who generously donated to help Women in Action and Compas through this difficult time of
unrest in Nicaragua. If you haven’t yet contributed, please consider making a donation today–your support will allow us to help those most affected by the current crisis.
There were several days during the unrest that we were not able to meet with the women and our project work was suspended. When we were able to meet, the women began to share stories of how the crisis has meant that they haven’t been able to work or feed their families.
We knew that the current crisis was going to most affect the impoverished; but we were deeply saddened when the women said that their families hadn’t eaten in days! Many had then resorted to trying to fish the highly polluted, Lake Managua, although few had any luck in catching fish.
The women began to cry uncontrollably as each one told their story—they have no idea how they are going to be able to feed their children, and they are extremely worried.
Hearing these heartbreaking stories, I found myself feeling selfish. I have been worried as well. Worried about the future of the country, and about how the current crisis will affect our small, non-profit, which relies partly on service learning trip groups for funding. I have also wondered about my 2 ½ year old daughter and if she might be able to start pre-school next year. I also worry about how we are going to maintain our family now that my wife is pregnant with our second child. The difference between my worries and those of the women? I have the option of packing up our stuff and moving to the U.S. and finding work there. The women are not that lucky.
Thanks to your generosity, our emergency campaign has raised over $3,000. We have since used a third of that to buy staple foods for the women and their families so that they will at least have rice and beans to eat in the coming weeks. It was heartbreaking to see the wide eyes of the children when they excitedly saw food being taken into their homes and exclaimed, “Mommy, mommy, now that we have food, please cook mommy, please cook right away!”
We felt like this was the best use of the funds in this critical time to ensure that the families at least had enough to eat. We will be using the rest of the funds raised so far to ensure the solvency of the WIA microlending bank and to be able to give a round of small loans to each family to help them get through this time of crisis. Here is a video of WIA receiving the food and supplies.
We still need funding for $2,000 to build the homes for the 4 women in action members who are most in need of a new roof. As well as funding moving forward for operating costs and to offset the loss of income from the cancelled service learning trips. If you are able, please consider making a donation–this is a critical time for our friends in Nicaragua!
Since the beginning of the political unrest, there have been many articles and publications with different perspectives about what has and is happening; and who or what was to blame. Many blame the government for corruption and for repressing unarmed, student protestors. Some blame the current crisis on a planned, right wing coup. Few seem to cover what is happening to people living on the margins. The people that we work with in Managua and in La Paz don’t have time for political analysis—they spend most of their time figuring out how to feed their families. They all pray for an immediate and peaceful end to the current crisis.
We will be posting updates in the coming weeks on our facebook page. We hope you can keep in touch and continue to support us as we work in solidarity with our friends in Nicaragua.
Thanks so much!
Compas de Nicaragua
Donate to Compas de Nicaragua and help sustain our projects!